Welcome back to Pokécharms! We've recently launched a new site and upgraded forums, so there may be a few teething issues as everything settles in. Please see our Relaunch FAQs for more information.
The original poster did not want this. In fact taking it down seems to me (by opinion of myself) to be of better interest than letting a blatant rip of someone else's work be allowed just because there's a technical loophole. What's being allowed here seems similar to "Stole this person's car...
@StellarWind Elsydeon that doesn't seem to answer my last question to you, but I expect nothing here. I suppose if @Teapot included stands with the "spirit" of this blatantly cracked mirror of a former member's work through the RP thread being justifiable, then who am I as some variable member...
So you're playing by the book on this one. You have no "spirit-of-the-rules" like qualms about letting it continue because of the technicalities, and this judgement is not influenced by your distaste for said former member and your previous quarrels with/concerning them?
So the overall conclusion here seems to be as you've stated and in short: If someone gets banned and started an RP original or not and it was in the threads and NOT the "creative corner" then it's free game to anyone who participated in it to grandfather said RP so as long as there isn't some...
Arguement? Where in this post am I committed to argue? I seek answers as a concerned member of this community. I merely seek clarity here. Am I not entitled to have opinions opposite of your own? I appreciate you taking time to at least try and clarify on this rip you stand behind though.
But reposting someone else's time developed RP and continuing a line is technically theft is it not? Regardless of whether her idea was "original" or not, she was the first to post it. When a person gets banned their posts and contributions can become another's project? ... Dang, I would like to...
So those who contribute the RP don't really have any sort of entitlenent huh? That sucks. So you're basically saying if I participate in a RP that's been copy/pasted and modified slightly, then I have stake and claim and can abstract 99% of it and then make my own "unoriginal idea" on RP thread...
Honestly I can't blame the young girl for wanting to come back to this amazing RP community. But where there's my wishing moderators would have eased up on the kid, I also wish she'd stop trying to return the underhanded way.
@StellarWind Elsydeon Some agree, some don't. When it comes down to a long story short, you basically outsmarted a 14 year old girl. Having said this however, It gives me both confidence and comfort to conclude that (this is a lot of c words) the head of regulations here is in fact a non-n00b ^-^
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.