• Welcome back to Pokécharms! We've recently launched a new site and upgraded forums, so there may be a few teething issues as everything settles in. Please see our Relaunch FAQs for more information.

Private/Closed Kanto league tournament (Reboot)

RP or Showdown.

  • Rp the battles

  • Do the battles on Showdown.

  • could care less.


Results are only viewable after voting.
How did 6 people vote? The only people that actually post here are Jagson, Hotshot, Roan, Sky, and me... And if I counted correctly that equals five.
 
Sorry about not ending it in that post. I'm on my phone so it was starting to get too long for just one post. I should be able to finish it in my next post.
 
Thank you that was so helpful. unlike most of you I have a job.

Also I guess I should give a defense for RPing the battles
first of those who are not into completive battling will usually end up getting swept.
secondly while Retro spoke of hoenn look at the original Kanto league tournament the battle between Drew and Yannick was completely RPed it only took a total of three days to do and In my opinion was the best battle in the first League tournament series. on the flip side in Johto look at yannick and... some girl I made up. there was barley anything other than saying what the attack was. and that was all based on a showdown battle.
 
That was what I was trying to express, but I guess I didn't explain it very well. Also take a look at the Sinnoh league tournament, it was all RP'ed and they have fair, and really cool battles.
 
So all we have to do is when we do showdown, afterwards we write it in RP style. One of the good reasons about doing showdown is that we atleast know who's going to win. Then all we have to do is creatively write the battle. So just do both. Do showdown to determine the winner. Then afterwards, creative do the battle in RP format.
 
Top