So here is my summery of events and characters
@GameBug03's Characters
Ren - A founding member of the United Swords (the main guild) and Co-Leader.
@SMRPG64's Characters
Richard - A founding member and Co-Leader of the United Swords.
Kayaba - Yep, it's him. He is still in his Heathcliff persona and joins them on their epic quests. Though the main villian recently stole his admin powers, rendering him just another player
Yui - A plot device more than a character but still, we had to add her
Boar King - Began as a one-time miniboss, who then became a side character and eventually became a key part of the floor two Dungeon's unlocking via a quest involving him
Bull King - Introduced in floor two, he was yet another plot device.
@Megacharizard's Characters
Luke - Current Leader of the United Swords and possessor of Tysword (more on that later
Jack - Some guy in the United Swords
Zey - A program, like Yui, who decided to make himself real for blah blah plot
Lizibeth - Yep we dragged HER into this too
@DarkEmporer's Characters
Ty - Ty was a founding member of the United Swords who tried to commit suicide by leaping headfirst into the floor two dubgeon alone. Luke punched him in the face and he exploded
Tysword - Ty didn't actually die, his soul split into two pieces. His consciousness was transferred into Luke's katana, which somehow made it able to summon dragons to kill his foes. He cannot jnteract with the outside world and nobody even knows he is there
Yirril - all of Ty's anger and hate built up in this adbominatipn, which is able to steal the very code from all he kills. He even hacked into Cardinal itself and stole Kayaba's Admin Powers, murdered the entire Holy Dragon Allience by himself, and is our main villian
Sam - Part of a Player Killing Killing Guild (kills player killers)
NOX - Leader of that guild
@Ace Trainer Kyra's Characters
I legitimately do not know please help
Now guilds
United Swords - The Main clearing guild and led by most of the main characters
Dark Sword - A player killer killing guild. Led by NoX
Holy Dragon Allience - Dead
Knights of the Blood Oath - Don't exist in this canon, Heathcliff joined the United Swords and Asuna is DEAD
Now that that's done with, here is the entire plot.
Floor One
Same as normal, big floating Kayaba.
We form the United Swords
We skewer the Boar King in some fields and get enough gold to get a guild house
The attack on the floor one boss seen in the Anime happens, but kirito is kicked out of the group because of being a beater, so they all died painfully and horribly. Luckily the United Swords were out... eating pizza or something?
Kirito leads the second attack on the boss, this time the Swords join in. Since we can't have in interfering in our plot, we kill (by we I mean the boss) of Kirito before I run in riding the BOAR KING and then we win.
Floor Two
Boar King as at war with the Bull King, if we end it we get access to the boss dungeons.
Through tough negotiations (with NPCs) we stop them fighting and enter the boss dungeon, or are about to until.
Ty decides to be suicidal and run in there himself. Richard and Heathcliff follow him via a convenient trail of mob drops
Luke reaches ty before the two and they begin fighting
Ty runs into the boss room with Luke and they kill the first mighty general of King Minos (yes that King Minos, it was my idea), single handedly, then Luke punches Ty in the face and Ty dies.
Via the power of Tysword, Luke kills the Second General, then Richard and Heathcliff arrive. The three get owned by King Minos but survive until help can arrive. (Cept Heathcliff cos he's immortal anyways)
They kill Minos
We timeskip to Floor Five
In between Timeskip
Luke gets forcefully booted from the game for unknown reasons which are assumed to have to do with Yirril's rise
Richard becomes leader along with Ren and Heathcliff.
They buy a castle and live in it
Floor Five
Richard travels across the land, searching far and wide. For the spirits of those killed by the Ghost King so he can unlock the Boss Dungeon. He kills the first four, only one left
Luke, being suicidal, leaps into the game again with the help of hackers. He then reclaims leader position because Wynaut
Sam arrives at Fort United Swords and talks with Luke about his cult, which he wants Luke to join.
Yirril murders THE ENTIRE HOLY DRAGON ALLIANCE before proceeding to take ALL of Heathcliff's powers
Heathcliff, Richard and Luke go to fight the <Phantom scythe>, the final spirit, and kill it to death.
Heathcliff realises he lost his powers, and contacts Yui, who begins an epic quest to gather enough A.I.s to Override Cardinal and get Heathcliff's powers back. Along the way she meets Tysword, and unlike everyone else can see/hear him.
Richard plans for the raid on the Ghost castle dungeon where the Ghost King lives.
Jack goes on his own epic quest to find a secret guild of builders in the mountain to get seige weaponary
Kayaba and Tysword have a nice little heart to heart