Ok, I decided you can have two profiles if:
They are in different Clans.
If it's a cat outside a clan you can't have it be the same type of cat. (Like two kittypets.)
Example of what your posts should be like (this is with my profiles)
ThunderClan camp, day. Mouseflower.
Mouseflower padded over to the fresh-kill pile. It was getting low.
RiverClan camp, day. Stonepelt.
Stonepelt woke up. He decided to restock his herbs.
Pretty much, you put the location and what cat it is. I think this makes it easier.
They are in different Clans.
If it's a cat outside a clan you can't have it be the same type of cat. (Like two kittypets.)
Example of what your posts should be like (this is with my profiles)
ThunderClan camp, day. Mouseflower.
Mouseflower padded over to the fresh-kill pile. It was getting low.
RiverClan camp, day. Stonepelt.
Stonepelt woke up. He decided to restock his herbs.
Pretty much, you put the location and what cat it is. I think this makes it easier.