NO! PIEH! Think about it. Pie is roughly equal, while with cake everyone is fighting over which size/piece they want. You may say, 'Cake has frosting!' Pie has filling. 'Some cake has filling!' Most pie comes with whipped cream. 'Cake is soft and fluffy!' Pie can be gooey, crunchy, or soft. 'Cake is... tasty!' Pie is tasty, and much healthier. Your argument is invalid.
Inserts the better dessert, Pieh.