Rileyixx said:But equally El and Rich are suspicious for wanting to abstain (to avoid killing Mafia perhaps)
Yoshimitsu said:Rileyixx said:But equally El and Rich are suspicious for wanting to abstain (to avoid killing Mafia perhaps)
How is not wanting to kill people blindly suspicious?
Rileyixx said:To try and avoid a Mafia member being lynched and in particular when you both voted. You voted when Shiny a person who is highly speculated at being Mafia was being voted for (perhaps to protect her) and Rich voted when all the evidence had been spilled out. Call me suspicious, paranoid or whatever but that is what I'm inferring
Red even stated he was fearful of both Carmi and Sho for being smart and cunning in the past and I think Brendan fits this criteria aswell so this makes me believe Red is mafia and trying to stay alive by taking out the big threatening force those 3 provide.
Shiny said:However, I'm also willing to lynch Sem only because he's a horrible leader in this game for whichever faction he's in because he's greedy and will probably want to take all the winnings for himself, as proven in... all the previous games.
Sir Red said:It would appear that I am being used as the scapegoat, though "oh, I've been accused? Better throw Red under the bus~! :V"
Rileyixx said:Wrote a list of 1-19 and assigned everyone to a number and used a random number generator. If anyone wants the exact list I'll happily write it out for them.
Sir Red said:Riley, if I was killing the people whom I deem the best players first, Katie would be so dead your head would be spinning.
I was a "driving force" behind Sho getting lynched because he had no fucking logic and he said he wanted Shiny dead despite not thinking she was Mafia! Why lynch somebody when you don't think they're Mafia? That's counterproductive to the Townsfolk. If you weren't suspicious of that, you're honestly an idiot.
Dwayna DragonFire said:Frankly at this point it seems that Red is being overly defensive of himself.
Fair point, El. I didn't mean to sound antagonizing, if it came off like that. I apologize if it did.Yoshimitsu said:Just as a random note, I have real issues with everyone who tries to use this argument. "Overly defensive" is not a thing that really happens. It's just normal defensive, exactly the same as it would be outside of a Mafia game if you accused someone of something. Everyone's pretty guilty of saying it (myself included, I know) but it doesn't make a lot of sense. It's basically jumping to conclusions when someone puts forth an argument to say they're not mafia. I get that the game's all about being suspicious of people, but I'm pretty certain there'll be other clues besides just "overly defensive".
Just thought I'd chip in with that.
Dwayna DragonFire said:Fair point, El. I didn't mean to sound antagonizing, if it came off like that. I apologize if it did.
Sir Red said:I also wanted to comment on Riley's random vote thing. I missed your mention of that in your initial post, but I myself had done the exact same thing in the past. I then got accused for it because the person I randomly accused was soon after killed by the mafia. So I don't fault you for being random, especially this early in the game.
Dark Soul said:I currently have zero suspicions against Dwayna or Ethan, but as it has turned out in the previous three rounds of Mafia I was in, I should not be trusting my gut feelings.
Still, I am prematurely voting for Shiny to be lynched, due to the reasoning from the last round where I voted for her as well. Second on my list is NidoRich- I'm still clinging to those two as the most suspicious.
There is an edit buttonDark Soul said:I'm just trying to be a little bit more professional about it this round, Riley- Although I can understand that it could be taken the wrong way, since I'm very likely not executing it the right way.
Also, Shiny? Your two most recent posts sounds more like threats then warnings, although that might just be me. I voted for you, and even if I wanted to alter my vote, I can't now. If it turns out you're innocent, I will be terribly, terribly sorry- But I don't think you are.