To be quite honest, @Shen: King of the Mist @Godjacob I don't care if someone obtains biju chakra or such.
What I do care about is the fairness of deciding.
And frankly, you both make no valid points other than the fact that you don't like it and think it won't work.
Shen, you claim a biju cloak would last five seconds than burn you up, when we both know that's not true, and is a rule you wanna establish here. By all means, if I'm wrong, show me some evidence, I'll admit I was.
Jacob...you've just been waiting for someone who agrees with you. XD
Tl;Dr This is a Naruto rp. Get used to the fact that people will try and absorb biju chakra.
I'm hardly die-hard for the chakra cloak. As far as I'm concerned the chakra cloaks are just how Biju chakra naturally manifests itself. I'm pretty sure Naruto wasn't managing the chakra control of the Shinobi Alliance after he passed on chakra to them.
All I really need to know is that absorption of Biju chakra is possible. How the chakra manifests itself is meh, and stats are buffed proportional to the amount of chakra used and hardly its form.
Okay, here is my cited source. There is no indication of a chakra cloak being stolen by someone in canon and no basis for it to just assume that the Hyuga chakra eating technique can both take and be able to give/perfectly use a chakra cloak.
The arguments for it are stretching at best. It's one thing to have something that "eats" chakra, it's another to use said technique to take a chakra cloak a unique attibute of a Jinchuriki and be able to use it and hand it out at one's leisure. Buffing a clan in no need of any buff to solve this one time issue.
The Chakra of a Biju has been stolen in a few cases. Samehada being the key example as it stole B's chakra cloak and was sharing the Biju chakra with Kisame.
Whether the chakra formed a cloak or not is less of a point compared to:
1) Stealing Biju chakra is possible
2) Biju Chakra buffs stats
which is all that really matters.
Anything beyond that is just for appearance sake, because as I'd said earlier. I believe someone would get buffed proportionally to the amount of chakra stolen.